#143 – All About Gingerbread with Sam Bilton
Who doesn’t love gingerbread? Yet how much do we know about it, really? Did you know it started life as medicine? That many of the earliest recipes didn’t even include ginger? That in France in the 1500s you couldn’t make it unless you’d studied as a baker for 4 years?
Sam Bilton, author of the wonderful book “First Catch Your Gingerbread,” joins us today as we nerd out over this precious treat. In addition to a wealth of curiosities, you’ll hear us talking about two gingerbready things close to our hearts:
Firstly, the history of oat gingerbread in the UK, including the ingredients most likely in Wordsworth’s favourite gingerbread.
Secondly, long-matured gingerbreads and how the historic experts tell us that leaving an uncooked gb mix to sit for months generated a better result. Alison has been doing this for the last 5 or 6 years and you’ll find her links explaining how in the show notes you can have a go as well.
Sam’s book, which, as you’ll hear, we highly recommend, has over 50 gingerbread recipes and, if you’re a supporter do check the downloads page because she’s been kind enough to gift one of our favourites to you.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Get more news from Alison & Andrea by signing up to their newsletter at the top of this page.
For more tips, inspiration and recipes, plus a free 30-page guide: Baking with Ancient Grains sign up for Alison’s newsletter here!
Get our two podcast cookbooks:
Alison’s course, Rye Sourdough Bread: Mastering The Basics
Alison’s Sowans oat fermentation course
Get 10% off US/Canada Bokashi supplies: click here and use code AKP.
Get 10% off UK Bokashi supplies.
Visit our (non-Amazon!) bookshop for a vast selection of ancestral cookbooks: US link here and UK link here.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Our podcast is supported by ancestral cooks around the world!
Come join our community! You can choose to simply sponsor the podcast, or select from a variety of levels with benefits including monthly live Zoom calls, a private podcast feed stuffed with bonus content from Alison and Andrea, and a Discord discussion group.
To read more about becoming a supporter and explore the various levels, click here!
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
The personal views and opinions of our guests do not necessarily reflect our own personal views or opinions. We recognize that our guests are whole persons and this may include views we or our audience actively disagree with; our guests are invited to the show because we feel they have something valuable to share with us all, and we do not ask them to censor their personal views on air. Our sharing of their work is not necessarily an endorsement of their personal views.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
We love 5* reviews on apple podcasts!
If you love the show here’s how to leave one:
- Open the Apple Podcast app
- Find Ancestral Kitchen Podcast in your library
- Scroll down to ‘ratings and reviews’
- Click on ‘write a review’, choose 5*s then let us know why you love us in the lower box.
Thank you. We really appreciate you taking the time to support us!
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Resources:
Find Sam: Website, Instagram, BlueSky, Podcast, Comfortably Hungry and Comfortably Hungry’s substack.
Get Sam Bilton’s book at the podcast online, non-Amazon bookstore… in the US or in the UK
If you are supporter (at the companionship level or above), here’s the wonderful gingerbread recipe Sam gifted
Alison’s long-matured gingerbread recipe:
https://ancestralkitchen.com/2022/10/18/how-to-make-fermented-gingerbread-cookies/
…if you specifically want to use oats, here’s her long-matured oat version:
https://ancestralkitchen.com/2023/11/08/fermented-oat-cookies-part-1/
https://ancestralkitchen.com/2023/12/12/fermented-oat-cookies-part-2/
Alison’s version of Grassmere Gingerbread (originally known as Rushbearer’s Gingerbread), along with some of the history of the treat, can be found in her free Heritage Oat Collection
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Do you have memories, documents, recipes or stories of those who cooked ancestrally? If so, we would love to hear from you! Visit our website here for how to share.
Thank you for listening – we’d love to connect more:
The podcast has a website here!
Alison is taking a break from Instagram. You can stay in touch with her via her newsletter at Ancestral Kitchen
The podcast is on Instagram at Ancestral Kitchen Podcast
The podcast is mixed and the music is written and recorded by Alison’s husband, Rob. Find him here: Robert Michael Kay
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Transcript:
Alison:
Hello, and welcome back to Ancestral Kitchen Podcast. Today, I have a guest with me, Sam Bilton, the food historian. Hello, Sam.
Sam:
Hello.
Alison:
Thank you for giving your time over to us today to talk about gingerbread, because you are the author of the book that I have sitting on my lap here, First Catch Your Gingerbread, which looks at the history of gingerbread going way back to ancient times. And the second half of the book is full of lots of gingerbread recipes, including some that you just wouldn’t expect to be in a gingerbread cookbook. Like last Christmas, I made the beef carbonard, which is in your book for Christmas Day, which has gingerbread in it.
Sam:
Oh, wow.
Alison:
Which was absolutely delicious. But I wasn’t expecting there to be a savory section in a gingerbread book, which surprised me. You also have your own podcast, Sam, called Comfortably hungry and sam’s also written other books including one on british saffron one called the philosophy of chocolate, and another one in collaboration with the globe theater here in the uk, which has got recipes in it inspired by the food that’s in shakespeare’s plays, so we’re going to talk about gingerbread today and the first question we ask all our guests sam is what was the last thing you ate?
Sam:
This is going to sound very poncy, because it was actually a medieval apple tart called Tartus Annapolis, because I have a food history festival that I’m involved in called Serve It Porth, and I wanted to make, I’m actually doing a panel discussion on how the Normans changed the way we eat because the Bay of Tapestry has arrived in Britain and everyone’s going Norman mad, or Bayer Tapestry mad. So, and I live in Sussex, so I’m not a million miles away from battle where the invasion took place or started, shall we say. So, yes, I made a medieval apple tart and that’s the last thing I ate.
Alison:
Tell us what this medieval apple tart has in it and how you made it.
Sam:
Okay, so it’s in a coffin, which is the food history, that’s a historical term for a pastry case. They would have been more sort of rudimentary, I’m going to say. The jury’s out on whether the pastry was actually eaten because we don’t have that many recipes from this period for pastry. But it’s a tart, basically, with apples, pears, dried figs, raisins, and spices. I mean, the problem with these recipes is that they don’t tell you. I mean, literally, that’s all you get. That’s the list of ingredients. There’s nothing to tell you how many or how to cook it or anything. No. And I actually, it does, the only spice it does mention is saffron because it says you need to make everything colored with saffron. And so this recipe is actually in my saffron book. Okay. But it’s, you know, it’s a lovely autumnal tart. It’s got warming spices. I think I use ginger, cinnamon and nutmeg and a pinch of cloves, but you could use mixed spice.
Alison:
And does it turn yellow with the saffron or not?
Sam:
Well, herein lies this. This is one of these issues with saffron. It was used as a colorant. It was used because it creates a beautiful golden hue in things. But when you mix it with spices, especially ground up spices like cinnamon and nutmeg, they are quite dark. So they tend to mute that yellow tone. So to mitigate that, in this particular version of the recipe, I use a saffron-coloured pastry. So the pastry is coloured with saffron.
Alison:
Oh, I see. Okay, so the pastry’s yellowish.
Sam:
The pastry is yellowish, yes.
Alison:
And is it an open tart with no pastry on the top?
Sam:
Well, again, the recipe does not specify a lid. I tend to put a lid on because that’s just the way I like it. I’ve made it both ways. It works either way um but i i tend to put a lid on these days um but the recipe doesn’t specify that i mean it is literally three lines of middle english that says i say gives you the ingredients and then tells you to put it in the coffin and make it well and that’s it yeah, okay and so.
Alison:
Did you have that for breakfast or was that yesterday you ate that.
Sam:
Um, I’m recording this in the morning. So it was yesterday evening. I had that.
Alison:
Yesterday evening. Lovely.
Sam:
For dessert. So yeah, it’s kind of got like a mince pie vibe.
Alison:
Yeah, with the spices.
Sam:
Yeah, mince pies back way back then would have had meat.
Alison:
Of course, yeah.
Sam:
But this one didn’t. So it’s just a fruit pie, but it is lovely.
Alison:
More than just a fruit pie, it sounds delicious. Cool. Okay. I want to explain, first of all, to listeners how I found you and how I came across this book. So, as most of our listeners know, I’ve been waist deep in research for a book about the history of oats in British kitchens. And earlier this year, I started on the sweet chapter, the treats chapter. And a big section of that is about gingerbread. Because in the northern regions of England and in Scotland, the regions that subsisted on oats as their cereal, often the only one that was grown there, they made gingerbreads that were made with oats. And I think we’ll probably get into this a little bit later in our chat but in that process I came across your book Sam and got myself a copy.
Alison:
I particularly like the recipes in the second half of the book as I said earlier, I love the history obviously because I do but, I enjoyed actually physically making the stuff as well because I always when I read history like you Sam I don’t want to just read the recipe I want to get in my kitchen and I want to do it and I want to taste it I want to see what it’s like to cook it.
Alison:
And as we were just talking about before we hit record, it’s virtually impossible for me to follow a recipe. So for some of the ones I’ve had a go at in your book, I’ve changed some of them. I don’t use wheat in my kitchen, so I’ve made them with ancient grains. But they’re very, very good. And one particular one that we loved and my son really loves are the nonettes, which are like little spicy muffins, ginger muffins. Um and um, Sam, you’ve been kind enough to say that we can reproduce that recipe for podcast supporters. So that will be available for podcast supporters to have a go. I have talked about it on our Discord forum because that was a big hit here. We also had a go, I also had a go at the 1700 version of Parkin, which is a traditional Yorkshire gingerbread.
Alison:
In addition, in these recipes at the back, like I said, there’s those savioury recipes and the beef carbonard is in there. And that really surprised me because I thought, wow, savoury and gingerbread. What? How’s that going to work? But it was amazing to see how the depth of the flavour of the gingerbread that I put in that beef carbonard just gave something incredible to it. And in actual fact, it was better the next day. I made it for Christmas Eve, for Christmas Day. By the time we got to Boxing Day, the flavour of the stew was even better because, all those flavours had time to sit. So I feel like your book really opened my eyes to not only the history of gingerbread, and specifically, you know, gave me more information on the oat and gingerbread, but also has helped me.
Alison:
Bring gingerbread more fully into my kitchen, which has been exciting. Thank you. Thank you for writing it, Sam.
Sam:
You’re welcome. I’m glad you’ve enjoyed it.
Alison:
I have, yeah. Can we start by talking about the origins of gingerbread? Who were the first people to make gingerbread and what was their gingerbread like?
Sam:
Well, that is one of those million-dollar questions, isn’t it? Because the short answer is nobody really knows because it’s kind of lost in the mists of time. There’s lots of theories as to where gingerbread originated. One of them is that it came from, Mongolia and that they used to ride into battle with this spiced bread, for want of better description I think having it’s not an area of the world I know an awful lot about to be honest modern or historically speaking but I spoke to, a couple of historians who are more knowledgeable food historians who are more knowledgeable and they seem to think that that was unlikely.
Sam:
Because they didn’t sort of have they didn’t think that it was likely to have come from there But, you know, we’ve had trade across the world in spices and… General goods anyway so it’s possible that it did get to that part of the world, we don’t really know so what we do know is that spices were incredibly valued um as you know there’s the spice route um coming through um, venice um and it probably started out, more as a medicine or what the early forms of gingerbread probably started out as more of a medicine than a, confection that we would eat as a treat. So ginger itself is renowned for its digestive properties. Confucius was said to have ginger before every meal, I believe. It’s, you know, if you think about when I think back to when I was pregnant, I was advised by my midwife to eat if I felt queasy to have ginger, ginger snap biscuits or ginger cookies.
Sam:
So I think what we can say is that we see… I mean, in terms of European history, obviously my expertise is British history. We don’t find recipes for gingerbread until I think the 15th century is the earliest one that I know of that’s been recorded as what I would call a proper gingerbread recipe. And it’s way different from what we think of gingerbread today, but actually in a cookery manuscript as opposed to a medical, as something that would be medicinal. But there are other sort of concoctions which might come close to being ginger or gingerbread. So, yes, I mean, as for the first people that made it, I don’t know. We don’t really know. I couldn’t find the answer to that. I mean, it was lockdown. So I was somewhat hamstrung in terms of where I could go for my research. The book ended up being very different to how I’d envisaged it when I originally pitched it to Prospect Books. I planned to do a lot more traveling and investigating, but alas, that wasn’t to happen.
Alison:
So, in the early chapters of the book, focus on the kind of ancient origins. And in that, you talk about what you just said, the fact that spices were highly valued and they were medicinal. But that it wasn’t a cake at that point, that those spices were often mixed with honey and then taken as a medicine, just like that. Yeah.
Sam:
Yeah, so you have this, and we’ll probably go on to talk about treacle in terms of what we think of treacle now or molasses now. But treacle in the sort of medieval period was something that had a combination of spices and it was mixed with honey rather than, treacle as we think of today. And it was a cure-all. I mean, literally, it would cure everything from, you know, a dog bite to, I don’t know, anything, probably syphilis. I don’t know. It was literally like if you were sick, it was taken. Yeah. And it stems from, it was particularly one of the things that it was supposed to be good for was poison, an antidote for poison. And this goes back to mithridatium, which I do write about it in the book. It’s quite, whether it actually existed, Mithridates was supposedly so fearful of being, poisoned that he developed this antidote, a cure-all for any poison. And it sort of backfired on him because he eventually got captured by his enemy and decided he and his daughters were going to commit suicide by poisoning themselves. Except he’d been taking this antidote for decades and it didn’t work.
Alison:
Oh, wow. So, it’s actually a really good antidote. Wow. It worked.
Sam:
Well, supposedly, I don’t know. I’m not recommending anyone give it a go.
Alison:
Obviously, you know.
Sam:
Um but that’s sort of when i sort of tell you about medicine that so that treacle in that.
Alison:
Turn and we had venice treacle um and.
Sam:
Eventually london treacle but venice treacle as you can imagine because of the spice trade it was this mixture of spices herbs and honey.
Alison:
That was.
Sam:
Taken so you can kind of see like you it i don’t know what it would have tasted like i imagine it probably tasted like most medicines.
Alison:
Not very nice not very nice.
Sam:
Equally um it was you know that’s kind of where we you can see how gingerbread
Sam:
may have evolved from that.
Alison:
Yeah okay it was um i was reading a fiction book earlier this year um just before i read your book, and it was set in venice in um when the plague was happening and okay that reference to the venetian treacle was in there some one family sent this guy out kind of um, clandestine wise to go and try and find some of this venetian treacle to um, help cure someone in the family who got the plague yeah and then when i read your book i was like oh that’s what it was i get it now yeah that’s what it was yeah so how did we go from a mixture which was spices and honey, and used as a cure-all you medicine to how we see gingerbread now so either a cake or in the UK what we call a biscuit how did that happen.
Sam:
Okay, so the first recipe, as I mentioned, that I know of in an English cookery manuscript, there may be others that exist in other European countries. But in England, we have a recipe which dates from the early 15th century. And it’s called gingerbread. And it’s a combination of honey and breadcrumbs. And uh it also has saffron cinnamon and pepper but curiously no ginger, and it’s interesting because a lot of people have said oh well it’s a it was a transcription error they were supposed to have ginger, but i’ve made this and i give it to people and um when i do my talks and my demonstrations and i say to everyone tell me what’s in that, and it’s quite an it’s this concoction of breadcrumbs and honey and spices is very different from what we expect because it’s kind of soft and chewy and, not really what you would classically think of as gingerbread. But when I give it to people, the first thing they say is, well, it’s got ginger in it.
Alison:
Wow. Okay.
Sam:
And there’s no ginger.
Alison:
Have you told them it’s gingerbread before that? Have you said this is gingerbread or would you just give them it to taste?
Sam:
I’ve done both.
Alison:
Okay. And they still think it’s got ginger in it.
Sam:
Yeah. I promise, I guarantee if people try this combination, it’s amazing how much like gingerbread it tastes. And that’s because you’ve got the heat. Ginger has this heat and pepper has the heat. And we, you know, we’ll talk about, I’m sure, about these combination of spices, but, you know, gingerbreads, even modern gingerbreads will usually contain…
Sam:
Cinnamon as well as ginger for example quite often nutmeg as well those warming spices it’s all that sort of that warmth so you know we have this early recipe and gingerbread was served as i say it was still had medical connotations because it was served at the end of the meal in the medieval era, and it was served as in as part of the um, the void of the voide which is the sort of the post meal if you like digestive period and, it was a it was taken to calm the stomach or soothe the stomach it was taken as a digestive you would eat gingerbread, at this period or at this time of the day to, yeah just to sort of round off your meal a bit like we would have I suppose after dinner mince now, yeah people who still serve after dinner mince but you know it’s that sort of thing um, and so at this point it starts you know being it was still a very luxury it was you have to imagine this is an incredibly luxurious treat though you’ve got very expensive spices um so only the very very.
Alison:
Rich are eating it.
Sam:
Yeah i mean even honey although you know, arguably if you could keep a hive yeah bees then you could have access to honey but it’s still you know it would have been made predominantly with you know the finest, um manchip loaves which are the white loaves so again it’s it wasn’t something that was it’s not like it is nowadays when you go into any coffee shop on the high street and buy a gingerbread man biscuit it was incredible it was, a wealthy thing it’s sort of the thing that people ate that when who were incredibly rich um about let’s say predominantly eaten at the end of the meal.
Alison:
And the name, you know, you said that some people have said that there was a transcription error and it was supposed to have ginger in it.
Sam:
Yeah.
Alison:
I know in your book you say that’s probably not the case from kind of other, people’s opinions on it. Why do you think it had the name ginger in it if there was no ginger in it? Do you know it?
Sam:
No. Because you also get things like pepper bread that don’t always have pepper in.
Alison:
Really?
Sam:
Just like you get gingerbread that doesn’t have ginger in, there are pepper bread recipes that don’t always, always have pepper in. I mean, quite often they do have pepper in, but they don’t, you know, so I think it’s just because the heat, the warmth that you get from those spices. And ginger and pepper have a similar profile in that regard. So I think, you know, it’s that.
Alison:
It’s reminiscent of ginger yeah it’s interesting it’s also interesting also because occasionally i’ve gone to make some things with ginger in my kitchen and found i’ve got no ginger, i didn’t get any ginger and there’s no shops close to me that sell ginger so that’s it i’m like i’m i’m stuck, and now i’m thinking if i didn’t have any ginger i could combine pepper saffron and cinnamon and basically make the same thing you know provide the same experience which is really interesting.
Sam:
Yeah i think the key is probably pepper because that has the same heat um and you know i think it’s, Yeah, you could try certainly using those as substitutes. But, you know, if you remember like curries, and we’re going off on a bit of a tangent here, but in the early days of, you know, colonial expansion, when we were, the East India Company was establishing its roots in India. They didn’t have chilies initially. I mean, they probably came via the Portuguese rather than us. But, you know, pepper, there are recipes from the Indian subcontinent that use pepper rather than chilies. And it’s whilst the kick isn’t quite the same, you do get a kick. So, you know, it’s that heat that you get from pepper and you get from ginger as well.
Alison:
So that’s, yeah. Thank you. I wanted to talk a little bit about rye and ginger together. I’m very much into rye and rye bread. I make rye bread every week in my house. And I remember when I was originally researching rye, just before I created the course that I have, coming across the French gingerbread, pan de piece. And I’ve made lots of different versions of that recipe in my own kitchen. My course has one of the versions of it in it. Can you talk a little bit about the history and the wonders of kind of rye in combination, with ginger and also panda piece and the area that it comes from and long mature gingerbreads in general because it has a history of being left for a very long time before being baked could you talk about that.
Sam:
Yeah so the i mean the french and about on the continent in general they have this as you say this history of using um rye in their gingerbreads and it does create quite a different, flavor and texture, I think it would be fair to say. Panda piece itself is… I don’t know. I mean, I would describe it as somewhere between a cake and a biscuit. It’s like either a soft cookie or… It’s not sponge cake i mean it’s quite it’s quite a unique texture i mean it’s lovely um, and you know that it’s been again of highly prized because of uh, the amount of the expensive ingredients that went into it, but they had you know gingerbread guilds certainly in france um and i’m sure in other parts of europe as well, and i think it was henry the fourth maybe in um in france i’m not very up on my henry’s in france to be fair but it was around sort of 1596 i believe yeah he decreed that um, to become a master gingerbread maker, you had to be at least 21 uh you had to serve a four-year apprenticeship and prove you how skills you were you had to make three gingerbread or pandepiece loaves, so um yes it was it was and it was you know this was serious stuff.
Alison:
When I read that in your book, I was like, wow, you had to study for four years just to make gingerbread. That just shows you how seriously they took it, how important it was, which is amazing.
Sam:
Yeah. So, I mean, Dijon is an area, I mean, a city I associate with gingerbread because I’ve, you know, I’ve been there a few times. And I mean, MFK Flisher talks about the aroma of gingerbread spreading throughout the city when they’re baking it and being thicker than flannel. I mean, because it’s so dense. I have to say, I didn’t have that experience. I don’t think they bake it quite as prolifically as even as she, I mean, I guess she was probably writing in the mid 20th century when she wrote those words. But it’s, you know, it’s interesting because I’ve used one of her recipes that she claims is from Dijon. And it’s, She puts mustard in hers.
Alison:
Oh, wow.
Sam:
Which again, I would never think of putting in a gingerbread recipe in the UK, but she includes mustard and it’s lovely. But one of the things that she does and actually was quite common and I still believe is very common is that panda piece, those are typically left for a period of time to mature. So they are, I think this particular, the MFK Fisher one is about a week, which isn’t very long at all, really. But it’s left over a period of time to… Not ferment, because it doesn’t really ferment at all. I think because the amount there’s too much sugar in the honey in these doughs to make them ferment per se. But it does allow the flavour to develop, a bit like you were saying with the carbonard of your birth. It allows the flavour of the dough to develop.
Sam:
And it’s something we did used to do in this country many, many years ago. And in fact uh francatelli has a recipe from about 1846, although it is a he claims it’s a swiss recipe and he does instruct you to leave i think his dough for three days i think it is but that’s like a honey-based again quite unusual for the 19th century in the uk it’s a, it’s a honey based uh gingerbread dough, um but frederick vine who produced a book for a very unsexy title saleable shop goods, he was writing for the commercial baking industry in around 1900 i believe or, maybe 1899 but we’ll call it the turn of the 20th century, he he bemoans the fact that We no longer let gingerbread doughs mature because he says, you know, actually we used to. And this is how he actually says, this is how you develop the best flavor with these gingerbread doughs. So he said, you know, by leaving them to mature, which is something, as I say, I believe is a common practice even now on the continent. And.
Sam:
It does make a difference. Because I have tried it, actually. I did make some and I left it in the garage inadvertently for too long. I went to do it for a couple of months and I think it ended up being… Over a year in the end because.
Alison:
I’d completely.
Sam:
Forgotten about it and it was fine I mean I’m still here.
Alison:
I baked some gingerbread I thought I was extreme so I’ve um maybe five or six years ago I started making long mature gingerbread about the same time that I did the rye course, and you know mixing up the flour and the honey and then just putting it in a ball and leaving I tried to leave it somewhere cool, you know when we were in Italy I left it in the bottom of the house to try and keep it as cool as possible and I left it for I think the longest I’ve left it for is three and a half months and it’s absolutely fine, and then I’ll make it into gingerbread you know a couple of weeks before Christmas or whenever I want the gingerbread and it tastes absolutely delicious I feel like there’s a difference in flavor between just mixing it up then and there and baking and leaving it, um so I I’m I think we should bring it back I think when I read that bit that quote from Vine in your book saying oh you know gingerbreads aren’t what they used to be because no one matures it anymore i thought oh yeah i’m i’m here maturing, i have um two recipes for long mature gingerbread on my um blog and i will put them in the show notes so if people are listening and they want to have a go at a long mature gingerbread, then um they can follow my instructions and it tastes absolutely really really wonderful yeah, i’ve never been to dijon at all so i haven’t.
Alison:
Been able to kind of see and experience um or taste what they’re doing there, um you were talking just before we recorded about having, non-ets the the recipe that I particularly like from your book in Dijon could you talk about that because I think listeners would love to hear.
Sam:
Yeah, so there’s, and unfortunately, I can’t remember the name of the shop, but there’s a famous shop. It’s a stunning shop, actually, to go into. It looks beautiful from the front, and I can tell you where it is. It’s on the street with the nail on the corner. I’m sorry. Anybody know Tijon? They probably know the street I’m talking about. It’s a beautiful shop, and it sells, I mean, look, there’s lots of gingerbread shops in Tijon. But they sell these nonnets and as you say you’ve made them yourself and there’s a recipe in my book they’re sort of muffin sized ones and, they’re sort of what I would call a normal sized cake but they make miniature ones which are like petit four size and they come in tubes and it is they’re quite addictive they fill them with a mixture of jams, the blackcurrant jam is very popular because cassis, creme de cassis is you know a thing from Dijon, So there’s blackcurrant ones, apricot ones, and you can also get orange, which perhaps not quite as tart as an orange marmalade, but lovely. I mean, I love marmalade. So, yeah, they are stunning. But they, I mean, the smell of these shops when you walk into them. I mean, people go on about chocolate shops, but oh my God, every day of the week I’d go to a gingerbread shop.
Alison:
Wow, that sounds delicious. So if anyone’s going to France, it’s worth taking a little detour to go and visit them.
Sam:
Yeah.
Alison:
Thank you.
Sam:
But again, even in France, they have, you know, regional variations. So, you know, you talked about the rye gingerbreads. Yeah. I think they’re more from northern France.
Alison:
Oh yeah, so that’s Reims.
Sam:
Isn’t it?
Alison:
That’s the city.
Sam:
Yeah.
Alison:
That is rye.
Sam:
So up there you get more of the, and again, there’s all these theories about the gingerbread. I mean, as I said, it has medicinal roots, but it never quite shrugged that off. I mean, there were people marketing gingerbread in sort of the 17th, 18th century in France saying it was good for getting rid of worms. It was just generally good for your health, for digestion reasons, as I talked about earlier. So it’s, you know, it’s different parts of the country and in different parts of Europe, you get these rye gingerbreads that, are, you know, because I guess that’s those parts of the world are where rye grew more prolifically. Yeah, yeah. Russia is another example. Ellen Malokovic has recipes for rye-based gingerbreads in her book. She was like the Russian equivalent of Mrs. Beaton in the late 19th century.
Alison:
Nice. I know that there’s, of course, the, I’m probably going to pronounce it completely wrong, but the Lebkuchen cookie, which is kind of in the Germany area, which again is a long matured one, which has that spicy palate to it as well. So there’s lots in that area that are using that technique and those flowers. Thank you.
Sam:
And actually, when we talk about ginger not being present in gingerbreads, quite often on the continent, ginger isn’t widely used as a spice, as a spicing element. It’s not always omitted, but an arguably panda piece, the clues in the name it’s spiced bread rather than gingerbread yeah but you know quite often in france they use things like anise um rather than ginger and cinnamon’s popular still of course but um, yeah it’s interesting how ginger i think we possibly have the sort of we’ve cornered the market on ginger gingery gingerbread shall we say in britain, we we fully embrace ginger big style I because.
Alison:
I really love anise, but I find it more difficult to find in this country. I went back to Italy to see a friend earlier in the year and I bought some anise. I absolutely love anise as a spice. I think it’s so overlooked. And so I’ve just been putting anise in everything because, you know, I can’t get enough of it at the moment because I’ve been missing it. But I feel like there are so many other choices for a spice bread if we just explore a bit. Ginger’s great. I’m not knocking ginger at all. But there are other options, and it’s fun to play with those as well and see how the flavours are different.
Sam:
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, I agree. Yeah.
Alison:
Let’s talk about another ingredient in traditional English gingerbread. Because as we know it today, gingerbread isn’t really made with honey like it originally was. You know, that honey and breadcrumbs mix that you’re talking about. But with that ingredient that you mentioned earlier, treacle. Which has its kind of linguistic roots in medicine, but now is applied to something else. Now, a lot of our listeners are American, and they won’t necessarily know what treacle is because it’s not a word that’s used over there. Could you talk a little bit about treacle and why it became the dominant sweetener in gingerbreads in England from the late 1600s?
Sam:
So, treacle is a byproduct of the sugar refining process. It’s the, as anyone, your listeners in America will know, they’d call it molasses. So it’s this thick, syrupy, very dark, I’m going to use the word gloopy. I can’t think of a better word to describe it. I mean, it’s… On its own, it is sweet, but there’s also sort of an almost bitter tang aftertaste to it. And the reason we start using, I mean, honey, obviously you’re dependent on the little bees producing the honey. And I don’t know much about beekeeping, but I imagine that there are peaks and troughs in the year when you have more honey than less honey. But whereas Treacle, because we sort of embraced, especially after 1655.
Sam:
When we won, if you like, Jamaica, we took over running of Jamaica and started really embracing the whole idea of sugar plantations and, eventually getting our own refineries. We’d already had refineries over here, but we sort of properly started getting involved in the sugar trade then in a big way, really big way. So we have this byproduct, treacle. And originally it was, again, all treacle did was replace honey in the medicinal aspects of, you know, in medicine. But we had too much. So it started to be used in cooking. Um it might the reason it maybe took that long to be embraced in cooking is perhaps because it was seen as a medicine yeah um probably seen as something a bit odd i imagine because it’s you know honey tends to be sort of golden and clear and lovely um whereas not you know depends where the honey’s come from but, obviously treacle is this dark mysterious substance, but we certainly know by the time we get to the late 1600s and early 1700s treacle is starting to appear in recipes, for gingerbreads now i know robert may’s book came out in around 1660.
Sam:
He was, has recipes for gingerbread which includes sugar. But fast forward a few decades, there’s a recipe that’s attributed to Charles II. I think the book, William Sam, doesn’t come out until 1705, but he attributes it as being a gingerbread that was enjoyed by Charles II. And he, I think he died around 1685. This gingerbread has a lot of treacle in it. It is treacle. There’s no sugar or any other sweetener in it. It’s just treacle. So we’re sort of looking from that period onwards and once you’re getting to the 1700s you do still occasionally see recipes for gingerbreads made with honey but treacle is the predominant sweetener in Britain at this point.
Alison:
And it’s a lot of treacle that’s what I’ve.
Sam:
Noticed in recipes.
Alison:
Like I’ve never I’ve been like really you want me to put that much treacle in it it’s substantial treacle yeah I it shocked me the quantities yeah.
Sam:
Yeah, I mean, we have to remember, though, that most of the recipes that we have from the 17th and really even into the 18th century, most of these recipes are written with a view to feeding a lot of people.
Alison:
Yeah, yeah.
Sam:
So, yeah. And also, if you think about it, if you were making a gingerbread dough and leaving it to mature, then you probably, you know, maybe only want to make one batch. And yeah, make lots of little batches like we wouldn’t do nowadays.
Alison:
Yeah. So when I when I was looking at some of the recipes, it was like six pounds of oats. I think I have to cut that down a little bit for my experimentation.
Sam:
Yes, definitely.
Alison:
I want to talk a little bit about oats and gingerbread now. so at the time you know we’re up to like 1700s now lots of regions in britain subsisted on oats and that availability of treacle, brought sweetness into homes and many people who hadn’t been able to to bring sweetness before you know either because they didn’t have honey or the honey was being used for mead um they were able to access that treacle and i think it’s kind of inevitable then that, they would combine that treacle with their staple grain the oats and make a sweet treat um in derbyshire i’ve done quite a lot of research on this in my book in derbyshire, farth cake was sweet and matriculant spices and then in yorkshire and lancashire which are a bit further north there was parking and then maybe most famously, certainly to tourists who come to the UK, is the region of the Lake District where William Wordsworth.
Alison:
Made his home in a town called Grasmere and there’s a very famous gingerbread now called Grasmere, gingerbread. There’s a wonderful quote from Dorothy Wordsworth’s diary where she talks about William wanting some gingerbread and her going out to a local household to purchase some gingerbread that they’d made. And gingerbread from that area, now called Grasmere gingerbread, still exists and so actually does that parking. But what I find most interesting about them is that they don’t really resemble, how they would have originally been made. So taking Grasmere gingerbread as an example, if you buy it now, it’s made of wheat. There’s not an oat in it. And yet, almost undoubtedly, the gingerbread of Grasmere that William Wordsworth tasted would have been made with oats. And i think through this kind of transformation of recipes, we can learn a lot about what a society can do to a food and i wondered if you had thoughts on that and could share um you know your your research around gingerbread in that area but also, things that you might have seen through other research you’ve done about you know what we do when we take recipes and we turn them into something else.
Sam:
Yeah. So you mentioned Dorothy Wordsworth. She goes on this hunt for gingerbread because William has said he wants some, but he wanted, I think he wants thick gingerbread and they only have thin gingerbread, which in itself is kind of like, well, what’s the difference? But I found a book that was compiled by, among others, Laura Mason, who was a very famous food historian, but there was like a collective of historians in sort of the Leeds area who, produced this book called A Ragu of Ducks. And they basically took a series of handwritten manuscripts, household manuscripts, mostly from the 19th century and compiled this tiny book really of recipes, and in there there were a number of gingerbread recipes and there indeed were recipes for because it was written they were northern managed manuscripts from people ladies writing in the who lived in north of england.
Sam:
They contain oats almost all of them but they are amazing in their different textures and there was indeed gingerbread there was a parking, as you’ve mentioned, which turned out to be like a classic parking, which is, kind of like an oaty cake wouldn’t you describe it as sort of like not quite spongy spongy but you know it’s it’s.
Alison:
Not squidgy squidgy but.
Sam:
It’s not a biscuit.
Alison:
Either it kind of gives when you when you when you bite into it and but yeah it’s it’s dense but yet cakey yeah.
Sam:
Yeah so there were other recipes in there one in particular that turned out to be I mean almost I guess like a biscuit it was, um to the point where you have to be quite careful about how you cooked it because it tended it didn’t have i can’t remember it had eggs in it or not but it it had a tendency to spread but okay again that was definitely more it was thin that was never ever going to be a thick biscuit, or thick sort of cakey thing so i think you know jane grigson, brings up this point that although William and Dorothy lived in Grassemere, that the gingerbread that he was hankering for was definitely not Grassemere gingerbread. I mean, that, I believe the recipe goes back to 1855 and it was, invented by, I can’t remember the name, Sarah.
Alison:
Sarah Nelson. I just know because I’ve been reading about it.
Sam:
Sarah Nelson. and they I believe that the recipe is still to this day kept in under lock and key so, they protect it and it is very different and we talked I talked earlier about the smell of, MFK Fisher saying about the smell of gingerbread in Dijon if you go to Grasmere and you are well you don’t even have to be that close the smell of gingerbread coming from the shop is utterly amazing, um but it’s very different it’s very crumbly almost shortbread like it’s, completely different from any gingerbread, uh i’ve had all that i know um and but i i doubt i’m sorry i’m listening to that are planning to visit the lake dish please buy grass me gingerbread it is lovely but i don’t it’s not the same thing, i don’t think it would have been what william wordsworth would have been familiar with yeah it’s.
Alison:
A fair point you know i i, have been trying to recreate oat-based gingerbreads of, you know, the 1700s, 1800s, to try and think, well, what are these confections that William Worsworth would have eaten and other people would have eaten? And then because I haven’t been to Grasmere, I ordered some of the gingerbread online and had it delivered.
Alison:
And like you said, it’s completely different compared to the oat and treacle, breads that I’d been making. The texture, the taste, the look, everything about it’s completely different. And like you said, it’s nice. And you can go to Grasmere today and you can buy it. And it’s a pleasant thing, but it’s certainly not, well, probably not, almost probably not, the gingerbread that that area was eating traditionally. And I just find it amazing that someone can come along and build a kind of a, you know, just at the right time when Victorian tourism was really, kicking in in that area with the railways and decide to create this and then build a whole tradition.
Alison:
With apparent historical roots around it on a recipe that has the things that, were probably the upwardly mobile people in Victorian England wanted. You know, it had the wheat flour in and it tasted in the way that they wanted it to taste. But it’s just not it’s not a true representation of probably the gingerbread that that area produced for many many hundreds of years i think it’s an it’s a, a wonderful interesting way to see how culture and the forces of economy and, what happens in our country can change a food into something completely different and then say oh this is this is our traditional gingerbread but But it’s not their traditional gingerbread.
Sam:
Well, that is interesting, isn’t it? Although, I mean, arguably now it’s been around for a long time. Yeah, you’re right. So it is traditional. It is historic. It is traditional. But no, you’re right. I can only assume that they wanted, I mean, hats off to them.
Sam:
To create, differentiate their product, create a USP, if you like, by creating something that was very different. I mean, gingerbreads, historic gingerbreads, we’re talking about once we get past the whole breadcrumb concoctions that I was talking about in the medieval and early modern period, they can be quite hard, shall we say. Yeah they can meet it realty so we had something called gingerbread nuts if you know they crop up quite frequently if you’re reading literature of the period even sort of in like dickens um people like that were talking about these gingerbread nuts and then, I’ve made them and they’re sort of like a small gingerbread cookie, but you, I mean, they’ve got no leavening in them generally. You just roll, make the dough and roll it and then cook them. And they, you end up with these hard biscuits. They’re quite small. And they used to have like gingerbread lotteries and stuff where you could win. Like, I don’t know, if you got the right, pick the right number, you got like a hundred gingerbread nuts. But there was one guy that was selling them saying, like, you know, my nuts are so, so wonderful that I don’t have to make them as big as other people. So you basically want a hundred miniature versions of something that’s already quite small.
Sam:
But they, you know, the texture of gingerbread, whether it had oats or wheat in it, was completely different to what we think of today. And it is, they’re lovely. And the spicing, it was interesting as well, because quite often they had ginger in. But a lot of these things like gingerbread nuts particularly would have things like caraway or coriander in okay um and there were recipes i say in this recipe collection from um north of england that have you know, those sort of flavorings in which we wouldn’t classically think of as being british gingerbreads but were quite common yeah in a way that they fall now
Sam:
favor completely nowadays.
Alison:
Yeah yeah um how did gingerbread get to america did it go over there when when people were moving from you know europe to america or did it did it get there some other way later.
Sam:
Yeah, so my understanding is that before Amelia Simmons wrote her book on American cookery, that most of the recipes that were being used were, from British manuscripts, unless of course you were in a part of the US or Canada that had other nationalities like French. I’m sure there’s a French equivalent, but not my area of expertise. So you’ve got books like Elizabeth Raffeld’s book going over there, Eliza Smith, Maria Rundle. These are all sort of authors writing the late 18th, early 19th century. And they would have been the source of these gingerbread recipes, which in themselves have probably come from way back. But each of those authors would have had recipes. And I believe Amelia Simons has something like six in her book.
Alison:
Oh, quite a lot. Okay.
Sam:
But even before that, there’s the Martha Washington collection of recipes, which I think goes back to the late 18th century or mid-18th century. And there’s quite a number of recipes in there for gingerbread as well. But I imagine they came over, as you say, with people emigrating from Europe or Britain to the US originally. And they just developed their um gingerbread culture over there and the way it was made so i’m guessing if you had for example um in pennsylvania i wouldn’t.
Alison:
Be surprised.
Sam:
If they have gingerbreads there that have dutch origins yeah for example.
Alison:
Yeah wonderful um let’s talk about the kind of practicalities of baking these gingerbreads there are so many recipes in your book you know the sweet ones you’ve got biscuits you’ve got griddle cakes you’ve got gingerbread you’ve got yeasted cakes, um you’ve got gingerbread cakes tell me what your experience of baking all of those different types of gingerbreads were and and which is your favorite one of those.
Sam:
Well, that’s a bit like picking my favourite child. I only have one child.
Alison:
So I’ll just choose the one.
Sam:
I have two, so I’m going to pick two favourites. But my experience was, well, it was lockdown. So everybody in the UK, we had this thing, baked gingerbread. Sorry, we had this thing, baked banana bread during lockdown. And I was baking gingerbread, a lot of gingerbread, because we were in lockdown. So I think I probably kept people like Steenberg’s and.
Sam:
By Whole Foods Online in business in terms of because I had to get all my specialist ingredients like the oats, for example, because, you know, supermarket shelves were bare and spices. I went through industrial quantities of ginger, as you can imagine, during this period. Yeah um the in terms of my favorites it’s hard to say i mean i think i started out writing a book about british gingerbreads but obviously i was drawn to those are crossovers and i was drawn to the differences in the continent and i had time on my hands even though i couldn’t physically go to places like poland yeah and uh which i did want to go to originally um, i had a little bit of knowledge about um and had a couple of recipe books from france okay french ginger so i was able to look at those and, i just like to say the fascinating how.
Sam:
Things are similar but different um so one of my favorite recipes is actually um from denmark no, lie it’s from sweden okay and it’s from an 18th century um cookbook author called um, kasia varg and i’ve probably pronounced that very badly so anyone who is from sweden or from uh of swedish descent, and i’ve pronounced that badly i apologize but she is like the swedish equivalent of uh hannah glass okay so she’s writing around about the same time so mid 18th century, and she has um a recipe for called smar pepper, pepper cackle which are a cardamom flavoured gingerbread snap. And I do love a gingerbread snap because, and there’s a classic English one, which has actually got pepper and ginger in. So they’re very spicy.
Sam:
In the book. But these gingerbread snaps, they’re just so lovely. They’re just amazing. They’re nice. They’re nice, light little biscuits. The closest thing I can think you could buy commercially off the top of my head is there’s a brand called Anna’s, which again, I think might originate in Scandinavia. I don’t know that it’s necessarily Swedish, it might be Danish, but anyway, these biscuits are absolutely divine. And I use, you know, you can crush them up and make them put them in the um beef stew you mentioned earlier yeah or you can, use them in like as a base for a cheesecake if you so desire or you can eat them with cheese which is my favorite way so i found the recipe.
Alison:
On page 116 in your book and i can see it’s got cinnamon cloves cardamom grains of paradise what’s.
Sam:
Going to paradise oh uh well i think it’s actually closely related to cardamom um okay similar kind of flavor uh, it’s different it’s not a spice that’s widely used these days um in cooking uh, it was widely used as this is why i like this recipe so much because in by this point in britain we’d stopped using grains of paradise in, traditional recipes food recipes um i believe it is quite widely used or was quite widely used for a long time in brewing but it’s it’s a i believe it’s, it’s related to cardamom and it’s it’s kind of a cardamomy peppery flavor it has a completely unique flavor to be honest you can get it from specialist suppliers like i say steenberg’s is stock it um i’m, sure there are other spice companies but you it’s not something you’re picking up in your supermarket you’ve.
Alison:
Got nutmeg as well lemon and orange and.
Sam:
A bit of rose water it’s a divine recipe it really is and that has to be my favorite, biscuit recipe um i mean i like all that it’s really hard to pick one but i i do like that one because it is unusual and it’s you know it’s i think just goes to show how what variety of gingerbread you can get um in terms of cakes, i mean i love a parking but there’s a recipe in the book called fucker bars um gingerbread which is a fruit gingerbread and that is lovely that’s a Okay.
Alison:
I don’t remember seeing that one. I have to go and look at that when we’ve finished.
Sam:
It is. That’s lovely. I also like the Dickens gingerbread, which has got a ridiculous amount of rum in it, but it’s lovely.
Alison:
Nice. What about the savoury section? Because we talked about the carbonara. In that savoury section, you’ve got terrines, you’ve got stews, you’ve got fish, which is just ginger and fish. You’ve got crumbles you’ve got a wellington meatballs sausages tortelloni camembert what’s your favorite recipe from that savory section.
Sam:
Well i do like the pumpkin tortelloni um okay it’s not, a historic recipe particularly but there are you can get pumpkin tortellini or tortelloni made with amaretto quite often includes amaretti biscuits yeah crumbled up amaretti and i I just thought, well, actually, I wonder whether, gingerbread would work well. You know, we have sort of… Pumpkin spice yeah exactly in a pump in like pumpkin pie and i just thought well why not in pasta and i i like it, i mean i know some i know someone early doors when the book first came out commented on i think amazon that they they found the savory recipes rather unappealing i would suggest they hadn’t actually tried any of them exactly have.
Alison:
You tried them that carbonard is not unappealing.
Sam:
No exactly well you know everyone’s a critic when they’re behind you know exactly when they’re just armed with a computer and they can just press send exactly and it it’s a personal preference you know i’m not you know, you can’t expect everyone to like everything and i’m fully aware that in writing recipe books that you know people will probably only make a handful of recipes from each but especially a book, devoted to gingerbread um but it’s it is i think used sparingly um gingerbread can, be great in savory recipes and i just you know it’s something that i think, yeah people should try so yeah pumpkin tortelloni or if you just want to give it a go to see what gingerbread is like with savory stuff try it with cheese it doesn’t have to be melted camembert, um but you know that’s a good place to start or just i say a simple cheese biscuit, sorry a simple ginger snap biscuit with some you know strong cheddar and see
Sam:
what you think I guarantee you won’t be disappointed I hope you won’t be disappointed.
Alison:
And did you you said it was lockdown when you were making all these recipes did you just feed them all to your family how did they feel about eating ginger all these gingerbreads like for must have been for months on end absolutely months uh.
Sam:
Yeah we we did go it has to be said, Obviously, there’s a big lag, I don’t know. There’s a lag between obviously, finishing a manuscript and it actually appearing on print. But even by the time the book came out, my family were very much like, please don’t make us any gingerbread.
Alison:
No more gingerbread, please.
Sam:
They’re fine now. I mean, I think the book came out in 2020. So it’s, you know, we’ve had a long time to get over it. So almost six years. But I mean, I love gingerbread and I still bake gingerbread because I love it so much and the family have got over it now. But the, you know, I think at the time when you write a single subject book, and I don’t know how your family are going to feel about the whole oats, but I suspect you’ve got a bit more variety. It won’t just be gingerbread.
Alison:
Yeah.
Sam:
But it’s that whole, you know, it’s quite intense. You know, the same was with the saffron, although we weren’t writing. I wasn’t, it was more of a mixed bag in terms of savory and sweet recipes. You know, it was like, oh god it’s got saffron in it again yeah you know, didn’t quite die of laughing which is apparently what can happen if you eat too much saffron according to one 18th century or 17th century physician didn’t happen to you didn’t happen to me uh, but yes we did get we did get a bit fed up with gingerbread during the recipe testing stage.
Alison:
Yeah i bet i bet wonderful is there anything else that we haven’t touched on or you’d like to talk about before we end sam Yeah.
Sam:
No, I don’t think so.
Alison:
No, wonderful.
Sam:
No, I mean, hopefully that was okay.
Alison:
Yeah, it was wonderful. And where can people find you online if they want to look you up and find out more about your book?
Sam:
Okay, so I have a website, sambilton.com, but you’ll find me on Instagram and bluesky at mrsbilton, but that’s with two S’s.
Alison:
Okay.
Sam:
And I have a sub stack as well that goes with a podcast called Comfortably Hungry.
Alison:
Wonderful. And your podcast, as I said, is called Comfortably Hungry and people can just find it wherever they listen to this podcast. Wonderful. Thank you ever so much for your time and sharing your expertise, Sam. I’ve really appreciated it. It’s a really fascinating episode and I know that listeners will love hearing.
